Physical Examination for Sciatica
A physical examination is essential for an accurate diagnosis. A physical examination will allow us to correlate your symptoms to a particular nerve that is causing your problems.
Think of the sciatic nerve as a river made up of many different streams.

Anything that blocks or narrows that contributing nerve has a downstream effect. We need to identify where this restriction is so we can target our treatment. It will also allow us to assess how profound your issue is and, sometimes, whether it merits further investigation such as an MRI scan.
We can organise private MRI scans very quickly and at an affordable price.
While an MRI scan does produce clear pictures of all the spinal anatomy it can often show changes that are harmless and asymptomatic. These changes may not be related to your physical pain. The value of a physical examination is that it does allow us to match our examination with imaging if necessary.
Our physical examination involves basic neurological tests. By checking your reflexes in your knee and ankle (elbow and wrist in the arm) we can check your nerve function. We’d also check your muscle strength as sometimes muscles can become weak because of trapped nerves.
This also gives us an indication of which nerves are impinged. We also checked the sensation of your skin in your legs as well and this also allows us to form a clinical correlation
At our clinic in Buxton, we assess patients from across the Peak District, Bakewell, High Peak and North Derbyshire, helping identify whether symptoms are caused by a herniated disc, spinal stenosis, piriformis syndrome, degenerative disc disease or another condition affecting the sciatic nerve.
Why Is a Physical Examination Important?
Sciatica is not a diagnosis in itself.
It is a symptom caused by irritation or compression of one or more nerves that make up the sciatic nerve. Think of the sciatic nerve as a river made up of many different streams. Anything that blocks or narrows that contributing nerve has a downstream effect. We need to identify where this restriction is.

A physical examination helps determine:
- Which nerve is affected
- Where the nerve is being irritated
- How severe the compression may be
- Whether muscles have become weak
- Whether sensation has changed
- Whether urgent treatment is needed
Most importantly, it helps distinguish sciatica from other causes of leg pain. Leg pain be also generated from the hip or knee. This is not as striaght forward as it sounds….believe me!!!
Your Assessment Starts Before You Are Examined
We begin assessing you the moment you walk into the room.
This tells us more than you think. We would look at;
- Your posture
- How you walk
- Whether you are limping
- Whether you struggle to sit down
- Whether you lean to one side
- Whether you can stand upright
These observations often provide valuable clues even before we do any tests.

Taking Your Medical History
Before any physical examination, we will ask detailed questions about your symptoms.
Typical questions include:
| What we ask | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| 🗓️ How did the pain start? After a trip, fall, lifting—or without an obvious reason? | Helps us understand the onset and whether an injury needs further investigation. Pain can also begin without a clear trigger. |
| 🦵 How far down your leg does pain travel? | The pattern helps guide examination of the back and nerves. Location alone cannot confirm the cause. |
| ↔️ Is one leg affected or both? | Helps identify the symptom pattern. New symptoms in both legs may require urgent assessment. |
| 🤧 Does coughing or sneezing increase pain? | Can occur with disc-related or nerve-root irritation, but does not confirm either on its own. |
| 🪑 Is sitting worse than walking? | Shows how different positions affect symptoms and helps tailor examination and activity advice. |
| 🧊 Do you have numbness? | Reduced feeling may suggest altered nerve function. We check its location and whether it is changing. |
| 🐜 Do you have pins and needles? | May indicate nerve irritation. The distribution, frequency and associated symptoms help guide assessment. |
| 💪 Have you noticed weakness? | May indicate reduced nerve function. New or worsening weakness needs prompt medical assessment. |
| 🚻 Any changes in bladder or bowel function? | New difficulty passing urine or loss of bladder or bowel control with back or leg pain can indicate serious nerve compression. This is very uncommon but if it is relevant Seek emergency assessment. |
These answers help narrow down the possible causes.
Looking at Your Spine
We will look at your lower back.
We assess:
- Spinal alignment
- Curvature
- Muscle spasm
- Where it hurts
- Protective muscle guarding
- Pelvic position
Often people with acute sciatica lean away from the painful side because their body is attempting to reduce pressure on the irritated nerve. We call this an ‘antalgic position’ and we see it alot. Often patients see this when they look in the mirror.
Assessing Your Movement
You will usually be asked to perform several movements if you are comfortable enough to do them.

Each movement provides useful diagnostic information.
For example:
Pain when bending forwards often suggests disc involvement.
Pain during extension may point towards spinal stenosis or facet joint irritation.
Palpation (Feeling the Spine)
We will gently feel the muscles and joints around your spine.
We assess:
- Muscle tightness
- Tenderness
- Swelling
- Joint stiffness
- Muscle guarding
Although touching the spine cannot diagnose a disc problem directly, it helps identify structures contributing to your symptoms.
Neurological Examination
One of the most important parts of a sciatica assessment is examining how well the nerves are functioning. This is neurlogical testing (click on this link for a more comprehensive description).
This usually includes:
- Muscle strength
- Reflexes
- Sensation
- Nerve tension tests
Together, these provide valuable information about nerve health.
Muscle Strength Testing
Compressed nerves may not simply cause pain.
They can also reduce muscle strength sometimes causing a weak foot.
Your clinician will test muscles supplied by different spinal nerves

| Movement Tested | Nerve Commonly Assessed |
|---|---|
| Lifting the big toe | L5 |
| Pulling the foot upwards | L4-L5 |
| Standing on heels | L4-L5 |
| Standing on tiptoes | S1 |
| Pushing the foot down | S1 |
| Knee extension | L3-L4 |
Weakness can indicate that a nerve is under significant pressure.
Reflex Testing
Reflexes help determine whether nerve signals are travelling normally.
Common reflexes tested include:
| Reflex | Main Nerve Root |
|---|---|
| Knee jerk | L3-L4 |
| Ankle jerk | S1 |
Reduced or absent reflexes can suggest nerve root compression.
Sensory Testing
We will gently assess sensation in your leg using light touch.
Different areas of skin correspond to different spinal nerves.
They may ask whether one side feels:
- Numb
- Less sensitive
- More sensitive
- Tingly
- Different compared to the opposite leg
This helps identify which nerve root may be affected.

Other Nerve Tests We Use

Screening for Red Flags
Every physical examination should include assessment for serious conditions that require urgent medical attention.

These include:
- Cauda equina syndrome
- Progressive muscle weakness
- Severe neurological deficit
- Infection
- Fracture
- Cancer affecting the spine
Symptoms such as loss of bladder or bowel control, numbness around the saddle area or rapidly worsening leg weakness require immediate emergency assessment.
Will I Need an MRI?
Not everyone requires an MRI scan.
Many people who come to see us improve with appropriate treatment following a thorough clinical assessment.
However, imaging may be recommended if:
- Symptoms are severe.
- Weakness is developing.
- Symptoms persist despite treatment.
- Surgery is being considered.
- Serious pathology is suspected.
We offer affordable and fast private MRI scans
MRI findings are interpreted alongside your examination because many people without pain have abnormal scans.
What Happens After the Examination?
Once the examination is complete, we will tell you
- The likely diagnosis
- Which nerve is affected
- The probable cause
- Whether further investigations are needed
- Your treatment options
- Expected recovery times
This allows treatment to be tailored specifically to your condition rather than simply treating symptoms.
Why Expert Assessment Matters
Many different conditions can produce symptoms that resemble sciatica.
These include:
- Herniated discs
- Spinal stenosis
- Piriformis syndrome
- Hip joint problems
- Sacroiliac joint dysfunction
- Peripheral nerve entrapment
- Vascular conditions
A careful physical examination helps distinguish between these conditions and guides the most appropriate treatment.
At our Buxton clinic, we combine detailed clinical assessment with advanced diagnostic reasoning to identify the underlying cause of sciatic nerve pain. Patients travel from Bakewell, the Peak District, High Peak and surrounding areas for specialist assessment of sciatica, trapped nerves, lumbar disc injuries and spinal stenosis.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a physical examination painful?
Most of the examination is gentle. Some tests may briefly reproduce your familiar symptoms, which can help identify the affected nerve, but your clinician will stop if discomfort becomes excessive.
Can a physical examination diagnose sciatica?
A detailed history and examination can strongly indicate sciatica and often identify the affected nerve root. An MRI may be recommended if symptoms are severe, persistent or if serious pathology is suspected.
Which test is most accurate?
No single test is definitive. Clinicians use a combination of neurological testing, movement assessment, and nerve tension tests to build an accurate diagnosis.
Do I always need an MRI?
No. Many patients can be diagnosed and treated successfully without imaging. MRI is generally reserved for specific clinical situations.
Can weakness in my leg be caused by sciatica?
Yes. Compression of certain lumbar nerve roots can reduce muscle strength, making it difficult to lift the foot, stand on tiptoes or control the leg. Progressive weakness should always be assessed promptly.
Key Takeaway
A thorough physical examination is one of the most valuable tools for diagnosing sciatica. By assessing movement, muscle strength, sensation, reflexes and nerve tension, an experienced clinician can often identify the underlying cause of your symptoms and develop a personalised treatment plan. Early assessment not only helps direct the right treatment but also identifies serious conditions that require urgent care, giving you the best chance of a safe and successful recovery.